Meaning
Provisions in liability insurance policies eliminate coverage for claims brought by one insured party against another under the same contract. This mechanism of the insured versus insured exclusion prevents collusive lawsuits where a company might sue its own directors to recover corporate losses from the insurer. The limitation does not apply to independent shareholder derivative actions or claims brought by bankruptcy trustees.
Prevention Purpose
Insurance companies draft these limitations to avoid funding internal disputes within a corporate structure. By enforcing the insured versus insured exclusion, underwriters ensure that policy resources are reserved for genuine third-party liabilities rather than family or boardroom feuds. This restriction keeps premium costs manageable by removing the risk of manufactured litigation between affiliated entities.
Coverage Exception
Modern policies frequently include carve-outs that restore coverage under specific conditions. For example, if a former executive brings a wrongful termination lawsuit, the insured versus insured exclusion is typically bypassed to allow the defense of that individual. Similarly, claims initiated by court-appointed receivers during insolvency proceedings are generally exempted because such parties act on behalf of external creditors.
Claim Dispute
Disputes often emerge regarding whether a claimant qualifies as an insured entity. Insurers will deny coverage if the litigation is assisted or funded by any current director of the firm.